| # | Name | Cl. | Pos. | Ht. | Hometown | Previous School |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kaitlin Antonneau | SO | T/R/M/X | Racine, Wis. | Horlick | ||
| Colton Barrett | SO | T/R | St. Paul, Minn. | |||
| Taylor Brown | SR | T/R | Fleetwood, Pa. | Oley Valley | ||
| Rob Bush | SR | T/R/X | 5-10 | Louisville, Ky. | Highlands Latin | |
| Alex Cannon | SO | R | ||||
| Myles Chandler | SO | R | Indianapolis, Ind. | Pike | ||
| Andrew Dalton | FR | M/R | Fishers, Ind. | Fishers | ||
| Peter Deucher | SR | R/X | 5-6 | Wakeman, Ohio | Firelands | |
| Allie Dragoo | JR | T/R/M | 5-8 | Grand Rapids, Mich. | East Grand Rapids | |
| Elizabeth Engwis | SO | T/R | 5-6 | Kenosha, Wis. | Tremper | |
| Neal Forbes | FR | R | Columbus, Ind. | North | ||
| Danny Gerow | JR | R | Grosse Pointe Farms, Mich. | University of Michigan | ||
| Matthew Giddings | FR | T/R | Manchester, England | |||
| Lisha Herold | FR | T/X/R | Oakdale, Minn. | North St. Paul | ||
| Jake Horvath | FR | M/R | Carmel, Ind. | Carmel | ||
| Mika Jackson | SR | R/T | 5-5 | Brownsburg, Ind. | Brownsburg | |
| Josh Johnson | FR | M/X/R | Fort Wayne, Ind. | |||
| John Kelley | FR | R | Carmel, Ind. | Carmel | ||
| Michael Kubancsek | JR | Greenwood, Ind. | Center Grove | |||
| Joe Kukolla | SR | Indianapolis, Ind. | Heritage Christian | |||
| Jackie Kurth | JR | Palm City, Florida | Martin County | |||
| Adam Leibovitz | SR | Indianapolis, Ind. | Lawrence Central | |||
| Weston Luzadder | JR | Carmel, Ind. | Carmel | |||
| Alder Martz | JR | R/M/X | Charlotte, N.C. | |||
| Zach McBride | SR | Comstock, Mich. | Comstock | |||
| Will Meger | FR | Eau Claire, Wis. | ||||
| Sinead Miller | SR | South Park, Pa. | South Park | |||
| Isaiah Newkirk | SR | Bloomington, Ind. | South | |||
| Coryn Rivera | FR | T/X/R | Marin, Calif. | |||
| Sam Stone | JR | North Freedom, Wis. | Baraboo | |||
| Stephanie Torres | FR | T/R | ||||
| David Yohe | SO | T/R | Willoughby, Ohio | South |
